A strong label can earn a first look. Taste can help earn a repeat order. For a first product, give flavor a careful trial with the people you hope will buy it.

Start with who drinks it, and when

Picture one real customer and one real moment. A drink before a morning workout, a drink at a desk in the afternoon and a drink shared on a game night call for different flavors. Write down the person, the time of day and what they drink now. Your flavor should feel at home in that moment.

Familiar or playful?

Flavor typeExamplesWhy choose itThe risk
Familiar fruitLemonade, fruit punch, green appleEasy to understand and describeHarder to stand out
Playful or nostalgicCotton candy, sour candyGets attention and looks good in photosSome people find it too sweet for every day
Cafe or trend styleBubble tea, tropical blendsFeels new. Gives you a story to tellFewer people know what to expect

If you will sell one product, a familiar flavor with a strong label is the safer start. If you will sell two, pair one familiar flavor with one that gets people talking.

Taste it the way a customer will

  1. Mix it exactly as the directions say. Same scoop, same amount of water.
  2. Use cold water first. Then try it again at room temperature.
  3. Note the first sip, the middle of the glass and the aftertaste. They can differ.
  4. Watch how it mixes. Look for clumps, foam and powder left at the bottom.
  5. Look at the color in a clear glass. That color will be in your photos.
  6. Smell the jar when you open it. It is the first thing a customer notices.
  7. Try it again the next day. A flavor that is fun once can be tiring by the third glass.

Let other people score it

Your own taste is one vote. Give samples to five to ten people who are like your customers. Do not tell them which one you prefer. Ask them to score each sample from 1 to 5.

Here is a made up scorecard for three samples, averaged across eight tasters.

Sample ASample BSample C
First sip4.53.84.1
Aftertaste3.04.23.9
Would drink daily2.94.03.6
Would tell a friend4.43.53.7

Sample A wins the first sip and gets people talking, but it loses on daily use. Sample B is the one people would finish a jar of. For a first product that depends on reorders, B is the better pick. A could be a strong second flavor later.

Ask what is in the flavor

Ask your manufacturer which sweeteners and colors are used, and whether the product contains any major food allergens. FDA names nine: milk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. FDA's food allergies page says the allergen labeling law covers dietary supplements too. Your customers will ask, so have the answer ready.

Make the name and the art match the jar

Call the flavor what it tastes like, and keep the artwork honest about what is inside. Before you design around a name, ask your manufacturer how the flavor should be described on the label.

Flavor choices at OSM

OSM's white label range offers premade powders in set flavors. A premade flavor is sold as it is. If you want a flavor of your own, that is a custom manufacturing project. Ask OSM which products are currently available and whether samples can be arranged.

Common questions

Can I choose a flavor without tasting it?

You can, but it is a gamble. Taste is the main reason people reorder.

How many flavors should I launch with?

One or two. Each flavor needs its own label, its own stock and its own sales.

What if my testers disagree?

Look at "would drink daily" first. It is the closest thing you have to a reorder.